Why Choose A Gastric Band Over A Gastric Sleeve

If you’re severely overweight or obese, you’re probably dealing with more than simply digits on the scale. Getting massively obese can put you at risk for diabetes, cardiovascular disease, fertility problems, stress, and several cancers. Obesity-related dangers can be significantly decreased or even removed with bariatric surgery. Patients who have bariatric surgery may become less reliant on diabetes medicine or no longer require it together.

Bariatric surgery has the potential to change your life. It will not only help you lose weight but also enhance your quality of living. If you’re dealing with life-threatening obesity and its implications, it’s understandable that you’d consider bariatric surgery – but whom should you go with?

Gastric band surgery and gastric sleeve operation are two of the most frequent bariatric surgeries. Both of these can assist you in losing more than half of your body mass. [1]

In this article, we will talk about why one should choose a gastric band over a gastric sleeve? So let’s get started!

A Brief Overview Of Both Procedures:

Gastric band

A major section of the stomach tract is removed during a gastric bypass treatment, allowing only a tiny pouch for food collection. The small intestine coming from the gastric pouch is likewise severed, and the intestine below this point is linked to the new stomach pouches.

As a result, incoming food “skips” the rest of the stomach and goes straight to the shorter small intestine. As a consequence, your body consumes a quarter of the energy it did previously. [2]

Gastric sleeve 

On the other hand, a gastric sleeve surgery does not alter the link between the intestine and the stomach, nor would it leave a piece of the stomach chamber inactive inside the system.

Rather, the surgeon merely eliminates a longitudinal piece of the stomach, providing you with a little, banana-shaped stomach that is otherwise completely operational.

You consume a significantly lower quantity of food here as well, leaving your body with lower-calorie to retain. [2]

Why choose a gastric band over a gastric sleeve?

Both gastric band and gastric sleeve operations are effective, but which one you pick will be determined by several criteria, including:

  • Absorption of nutrients
  • Health problems that come with it
  • Expenses
  • Obesity’s severity
  • Now we’ll be discussing some of the important factors that will make your choice crystal clear.

Absorption of nutrients:

Although gastric sleeve surgery restricts the quantity of food you can eat, it has no effects on meeting nutritional requirements.

Losing a part of the gastrointestinal tract during gastric bypass surgery makes it difficult to absorb the nutrients, necessitating supplementation.

Health problems that come with it:

Suppose you’re seeking to manage obesity-related illnesses like diabetes, high blood pressure, or sleep problems. In that case, you should realize that gastric bypass surgery is probably more efficient than gastric sleeve surgery at doing so, while both procedures can assist.


Even though lap-band surgery, a type of bariatric surgery, is less expensive than either of gastric operations, gastric bypass is typically less expensive than a gastric sleeve.

Obesity’s severity:

You should choose gastric bypass over gastric sleeve the more obese you are. This more invasive technique can sometimes result in more significant weight loss. [3]

Benefits of gastric banding

Reversible: Moreover, the gastric band is made to be flexible as well as detachable. If you are unhappy with the band after just a short time, you can have it removed by some other laparoscopic operation.

Decent Results: Although adjustable gastric banding is not as successful as gastric sleeve or gastric bypass, it can help you remove up to 50% of your excessive fat.

Fewer Complications: Gastric banding has fewer problems since the only incisions necessary to implant the laparoscope and put the abdominal line. [4]

Although gastric banding does not need stomach surgery, it does necessitate postoperative dietary requirements and follow-up appointments. Following up with your doctor regularly is critical to your weight reduction progress and general wellbeing. Aside from the risks associated with other weight-loss operations, the band has its own set of consequences, including blockage, band slippage, esophageal dilatation, and inadequate nutrition. It’s critical to think about all of your weight-loss surgery alternatives thoroughly.

It’s time to look outside the box if you’re tired of depending on conventional losing weight strategies to achieve the body you’ve always desired. You should be aware of the difficulties and select the most appropriate surgical procedure to assist you in reaching your goals.

The Bottom Line:

On average gastric bypass patients lose about 70% of their excess weight. Gastric sleeve patients lose about 60% of their excess weight. Hence the patients who undergo gastric banding get more desired results than the gastric sleeve.


  1. Lap-Band vs. Gastric Sleeve W. Lap-Band vs. Gastric Sleeve, Which Procedure is Right for Me? [Internet]. Cernero Surgery & Aesthetics. 2021 [cited 8 November 2021]. Available from: https://www.cernerosurgery.com/bariatric-surgery/lap-band-vs-gastric-sleeve/
  2. Gastric Sleeve vs. Gastric Bypass: Differences, Pros, Cons [Internet]. Healthline. 2021 [cited 8 November 2021]. Available from: https://www.healthline.com/health/gastric-sleeve-vs-gastric-bypass#recovery
  3. Gastric Bypass vs. Gastric Sleeve: Which One Is Right for You? [Internet]. Olde Del Mar Surgical. 2021 [cited 8 November 2021]. Available from: https://oldedelmarsurgical.com/blog/gastric-bypass-vs-gastric-sleeve/
  4. Bypass G, Balloons G, AspireAssist T, Therapy M, Medication W, Stories S et al. Gastric Banding Vs. Gastric Sleeve: What’s The Difference? – True You Weight Loss [Internet]. True You Weight Loss. 2021 [cited 8 November 2021]. Available from: https://trueyouweightloss.com/blog/gastric-banding-vs-gastric-sleeve-whats-the-difference/
  5. Gastric bands: How it works, surgery, who should have it [Internet]. Medicalnewstoday.com. 2021 [cited 8 November 2021]. Available from: https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/298313